Financial state Ministry rebuffs Haredi minister, says rail function on Shabbat will continue

The Economic climate Ministry on Sunday rejected strain to halt routine servicing function on Shabbat, just after a letter from United Torah Judaism head MK Yitzhak Goldknopf demanded these kinds of functions be stopped all through the weekly Jewish day of rest.

In a statement Sunday, the ministry said this sort of will work “have normally been carried out inside the framework of Israel Railways’s allow to have out servicing and security work.”

“There is no intention to cancel them,” it pressured.

Goldknopf experienced claimed that coalition agreements in between UTJ and Primary Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud bash had stipulated that “this work would conclusion.”

The rail firm does not operate on Shabbat, and the apply of carrying out servicing perform all through the working day of stoppage is intended to protect against, as considerably as possible, disruption to the service’s typical schedule.

According to a Channel 12 report, Transportation Minister Miri Regev held a assembly on Sunday night to address the problem, where by it was agreed that Israel Railways would present “solutions” for minimizing function performed on Shabbat by the stop of the 7 days.

UTJ head Yitzhak Goldknopf during a discussion previous forming Israel’s 37th federal government, December 29, 2022. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

“The position quo with regards to the railway operate on Shabbat will be managed as it was in the [previous] Netanyahu governments,” she mentioned.

The report also explained Regev experienced made available two ostensible concessions to placate Goldknopf: To begin with, that staff operating on Saturday would be non-Jewish, and secondly, that operate would not be conducted in close proximity to Synagogues. Even so, the community noted that these disorders are previously mostly realized.

In a Saturday night letter, Goldknopf wrote to Regev: “It has been introduced to my focus that there is get the job done on Shabbat at Israel Railways that does not satisfy the definition of preserving life” (a religious normal that enables breaking Shabbat prohibitions of get the job done beneath extreme circumstances).

Former CEO of Israel Railways Shahar Ayalon instructed the Maariv news outlet on Sunday that he far too had faced identical pressures from extremely-Orthodox politicians in the earlier.

Asked whether or not it was attainable to avoid carrying out function on Shabbat, Ayalon responded: “Anything is possible, but then you won’t have trains on Sunday, only on Monday.” He extra that “the expense would be congested streets for all of us.”

“We really do not have quite a few diverse traces that we can use for trains when there is upkeep work. Hence, you cannot do the upkeep operate on a weekday simply because the trains are on the tracks at that time… it would be a important catastrophe,” he reported.

Ayalon also pointed out that Haredi society, due to low fees of privately owned cars, is extremely dependent on community transportation, including intercity trains, and would be disproportionately influenced by the prevention of routine maintenance function on Shabbat.

UTJ has prolonged taken problem with public works projects on the Sabbath and has earlier pushed practice routine maintenance to the fore of coalition crises. The get together tried to demand from customers that electric power plants halt producing electricity on Shabbat in December, but Likud turned down the proposal.

Carrie Keller-Lynn contributed to this report.

You’re a focused reader

Which is why we commenced the Occasions of Israel ten yrs ago – to give discerning readers like you with have to-browse coverage of Israel and the Jewish world.

So now we have a ask for. Contrary to other information shops, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is highly-priced, we invite readers for whom The Occasions of Israel has become significant to aid aid our do the job by signing up for The Situations of Israel Local community.

For as little as $6 a thirty day period you can help assistance our excellent journalism when making the most of The Occasions of Israel Advertisement-Totally free, as perfectly as accessing distinctive written content available only to Times of Israel Community customers.

Thank you,
David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel

Sign up for Our Local community

Join Our Local community

Now a member? Indication in to stop looking at this

Leave a Reply